Comment by lifeisloving

7 hours ago

It can clone photoshop.. Have you considered why?

The ability to clean room Adobe products came at about the same time Claude's RE abilities suddenly improved.. Hmm lets think about this a little more.

Anthropic sucked the bones dry of the public domain, literature and all of opensource. It seems likely that Anthropic RL'd Claude into being a great reverse engineer because it needed more training data.

I believe that Anthropic turned Claude into a digital software shredder and started decomping proprietary code, like adobes.

So the reason Claude can suddenly clean room Photoshop isnt because it became a more capable programmer, but rather, the Adobe code is literally in its training data now.

Ciscos internal legacy code is not going to be in Claude's data (yet).

The decision to increase Claudes ability to RE is brilliant, because now everyone is doing the source code decomp for them, and sending them fresh data from previously closed source repositories of code.

Your comment is nothing but supposition

  • So is any other hypothesis about why Claude can RE now... You just want to default to some worldview where AI isn't being gamed for certain outcomes, and is some evolving intelligent thing.

    Thanks for the very thought provoking reply tho!!!!!!!!!!!