Comment by gus_massa

18 days ago

That's strange. Here in Argentina at least half of the MP must be present[1] to get a valid vote and send it to the senate.

[1] Actually, seated in their seats! There is a detector and if they are standing they don't count as present.

It's baffling how it isn't 100% present, since any law once passed will affect 100% of the population. It isn't like a law only applies to jurisdictions where the MPs were present for the vote.

  • One of them can have a very bad diarrhea, or go to the UN meeting to protect baby seals or something.

    Here we require 50%+ present and to partially approve the law 50%+ of the present. So sniping correctly, a 25% is enough.

    There is a weird iteration, when on party ensure 49% of the total of positive votes. Sometimes they have a dubious 3% of the votes of abstention from other parties that is a shame/hidden way to vote in favor. The 48% MP of the other party hide nearby while there is only 49% present, but if the 3% appear then they must rush in and vote against.

    49% yes --> not aproved

    49% yes + 3% abstention --> aproved

    49% yes + 3% abstention + 48% no --> not aproved

    I'd prefer 50%+ of the total for everything. (Note that 50% is required for some special topics, so it's not ridiculous to ask it for everything.)