Comment by anonymous908213

11 days ago

Funny, I was just talking about this on HN a couple of days ago[0..2] and had a thread full of anklebiters telling me I'm using Luna wrong. It's clear that the vast majority of people never privately benchmark, because anyone who does knows models like Luna aren't remotely close to the performance the published benchmarks claim, immediately failing when even a single unexpected specification is introduced, no matter how trivial it is, exactly like Maxxbench's "filename must be lowercase". It's nice to have a public one to point to, but unfortunately every time you publish your private benchmarks they become targets for the next round, and as soon as the next generation of models releases you're back to arguing with people who take benchmaxxed results at face value.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50373961 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50374111

Yeah Luna has been extremely disappointing for me despite what the benchmark numbers show

you completely missed the point that the "ankle biters" were making - smaller models can still be useful despite being less intelligent. nobody makes the argument that luna is just as smart as opus, but they do make the argument that someone sufficiently knowledgeable and skilled can use smaller models to great effect. just because you and others require the maximally powerful models to make sense of vague, underspecified prompts, to hold your hand throughout the entire development lifecycle and make decisions for you, does not mean we all do.

  • > underspecified prompts

    This is the same stupid argument trotted out repeatedly in the thread, and it doesn't hold up to reality. Would you care to explain how adding specifications helps a model that demonstrably ignores specifications? A model that cannot even handle the trivial specification of "the filename must be lowercase" is not going to get better when you add more specifications it ignores. I would guess that you're actually significantly underspecifying relative to me. Perhaps you're happy with whatever slop you get and don't notice Luna's overwhelming incapability to actually provide what one requires, because you don't have requirements.

    • yes, your prompts are underspecified relative to the size of changes you are making. you want to write a handful of paragraphs and have a sota model vibe out a +1000loc diff, where it makes all sorts of decisions and architectural/functional choices for you (that you didn't even realise needed to be made). if you use a smaller model, it's just not going to be sufficient. you need to work more iteratively with the model, with more steering and more human judgement. astra/opus can do this relatively well in some domains, especially the relatively simple ones like web, agent harnesses, etc. but someone with intention and skill can make use of the less powerful models, it's just a different workflow (and one that I prefer, when I'm not being lazy).

      8 replies →