Comment by kasabali

9 days ago

> Even YouTube is preparing to move beyond AV1 and begin streaming video using AV2, potentially as early as 2027. If a company handling the enormous amount of video that YouTube does sees the benefits of a more efficient format, shouldn't the rest of the internet be taking a closer look at what we can do with images and video too?

Odd argument.

Image isn’t video and we are not YouTube.

AV1 (and AV2) do save a lot of bandwidth, and Youtube already serves AV1 selectively to some users. But the biggest drawback of AV1 is that it needs more resources to even decode. This is especially apparent on old computers that don't have dedicated AV1 encoders or decoders. I discovered this when someone complained to me that PaleMoon on their old PC suddenly consumed a lot of CPU resource causing the PC to stutter - turned out that Youtube was serving AV1 encoded videos on it. Disabling AV1 support in the browser fixed it as Youtube was then forced to serve AVC / H.264 encoded videos.

not an odd argument. AVIF is based on AV1, so what they mean is that since we accept YouTube's AV1 usage as mainstream nowadays, so should be it's image part

  • Youtube doesn't prefer AV1 at least on my M1 Mac, which can't natively decode it. I get VP9, which is hardware accelerated.

    So please don't ruin my battery life just to save a few percent on your egress traffic bill.

It's a super strange backwards argument: lots of tiny efficiencies make sense when you're operating at a Google or Amazon scale that make zero sense in other contexts.