Comment by ateng
4 years ago
I think pointing out that it is published on a known journal is to display the fact that the paper is now peer-reviewed
4 years ago
I think pointing out that it is published on a known journal is to display the fact that the paper is now peer-reviewed
Yes, that’s right. I wanted to highlight that this is a peer-reviewed article published in one of the top statistical journals.
Peer reviews dont mean much anymore these days.
Do you have a measure of low correlation to support that?
Regardless, I expect reviews are pretty straight forward for a concept that stands on its own like this one.
In answer to sister comment by derbOac:
Thanks for sharing this. On the other hand the cited paper clearly relates to interdisciplinary peer review.
I am not sure how or if this can be transferred to mathematics.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-017-2516-6
Perhaps to you. In academia we take them seriously.
In Math they really do.